Like you, I watched the reactions to Kapil Sibal’s alleged dream of pre-screening the internet. It was easy to see that some of the reactions were at most paranoia. Sibal sat down with Karan Thapar on Devil’s Advocate a couple of days ago. Watch it if you are interested in the issue.
Free speech absolutists such as I will have some disagreement with Sibal but he is by and large reasonable. And that is important to acknowledge. At best this is a disagreement where one side (I) is not in control and the other side is in control but not being outrageous.
I can live with that.
Those five words are perhaps the most important life-lesson I have learnt recently. I don’t need to give a fuck about everything. I don’t need to be paranoid about everything that isn’t exactly how I want it to be.
And I don’t need to jump in with a pitchfork every time someone deviates from absolute free speech.

3 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 17, 2011 at 10:19 am
amit
i think karan was very soft on him. there were several moments when Karan could have grilled him, or at least Karan has grilled other politicians on similar moments. For e.g. the point that why didnt Kapil go the FIR route to get those content removed he said that it was not a practical way…
I can only imagine the practical horrors of common citizen.
December 17, 2011 at 11:10 am
Deepak
It could be a combination of Karan not being great lately and the editing of long interviews to fit into 20 mins. I was glad we atleast got to hear what Sibal’s point is.
The issue, if any, is that India has strict and subjective limitations on free speech. Sibal’s current crusade is legal under that definition.
BTW, what practical horrors are you imagining?
December 18, 2011 at 7:59 am
amit
filing FIR is horror in itself…
why does he want to fix something when its not a problem yet. Of all places at least content on internet is not cause of any issue/riot/discord. an open forum gives a platform to vent out intolerance. And I believe this venting out is a fad… people are becoming intolerant to intolerance these days…